top of page

Is Your Investing Based on Historical Data Alone, or a View of What Comes Next?

Shwealth
Nov 2
6 min read


Deep research is where good advice starts. A forward-looking view is what you should be basing decisions on.



When it comes to investment decisions, most people, and frankly most advisors, rely primarily on historical data. To be fair, that’s not entirely wrong. History is the only concrete evidence we have. I am myself obsessed with looking at data from multiple angles and have developed various tools that assist me in doing that.

  • Level 1 analysis: Look at the last 5-10 year best performers and invest in them.

  • Level 2 analysis: Use rolling returns and risk-adjusted returns.

  • Level 3 analysis: Look at drawdowns, and map funds to your time horizon and risk appetite.


But even Level 3 is still about the past. It tells you what happened, not what comes next.

And here’s the uncomfortable reality: most people can read historical data. A basic screener, a fund comparison tool or a well-designed app can show you which funds outperformed over the last 5 or 10 years. What separates a useful advisor from an expensive data terminal is harder to quantify: understanding the why behind the numbers, and forming a considered view on what comes next. That view may go wrong, and more often than not it will, at least in part. The value lies in a well-reasoned view, held with humility and sized sensibly within a portfolio.


The midcap story: hindsight or insight?


Between 2014 and 2020, the data showed clear promise in midcaps and smallcaps. Yet many investors, and advisors, stayed in large caps, haunted by memories of 2008 and how long smaller companies took to recover.

That caution wasn’t irrational. But it missed something important. The structure of the segment had changed:

  • These were no longer purely promoter-driven businesses with governance question marks.

  • Access to capital had improved dramatically, so growth was no longer starved of funding.

  • FIIs were taking serious interest in the segment.

  • Revenue, orders and genuine business opportunities were materialising, not just speculation.


There was a rough patch in 2018-19, and anyone holding through it had a tough time. But investors who stayed invested from 2013-14 still ended up ahead of large caps on an XIRR basis. I’d argue that recognising the structural shift was insight, not just hindsight: looking at the same data as everyone else, understanding what lay underneath it, and forming a forward-looking view.


That is the difference between reading history and understanding it.


Gold: when history said “don’t bother”

For years, many investors and advisors read the historical data, and a few wrote gold off. After its earlier peak, gold went through a long stretch of lagging equities. It produces no cash flow, and it doesn’t fit neatly into an equity-versus-debt framework. Even at a 9% return, it trailed equities, so on the numbers alone the case for ignoring it looked reasonable.

But the data was telling an incomplete story. In my view, the drivers underneath had changed:

  • Central banks around the world began buying gold in large quantities, especially after the freezing of Russia’s reserves in 2022 made countries rethink how safe their dollar holdings really were.

  • Geopolitical uncertainty kept rising, and investors wanted something that doesn’t depend on anyone’s promise to pay.

  • A weakening rupee added to gold’s returns for Indian investors.


None of this showed up in a historical returns table. It was visible only to those asking why gold might behave differently from here on. Gold then went on to deliver stellar returns.

For context, take equal monthly SIPs started in January 2014 in the UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund and the SBI Gold Fund. Up to December 2022, the Nifty 50 SIP would have given an XIRR of 14.4% and gold 9%. Remember that gold is meant to be a hedge and a diversifier, not something to beat equity returns, and 9% is reasonable enough. But here comes the shocker: had the SIPs continued until October 2026, the Nifty 50 XIRR would have dropped to 10.2% and gold would be at 17.7%. On an absolute corpus basis, gold would have given a corpus about 70% higher.


The lesson isn’t that gold always works. It spent long stretches doing nothing, and after a sharp run it deserves the same valuation scepticism as anything else. The lesson is that “gold has trailed equities for years, so ignore it” was reading history, not understanding it.


What does the forward view look like now?

The question today isn’t what happened over the last decade. It is whether the structural case for midcaps and smallcaps is still intact. I believe it is, for three reasons.

India’s growth story is real, not just projected. India is widely expected to keep the highest GDP growth among major economies. But more telling than forecasts is what you hear on the ground. Speak to people working in, or leading, multinationals and the message is consistent: India is the priority market, where growth is being earmarked, while many other geographies are flat or declining. That ground-level signal matters as much as the macro number.

Large caps are facing competition from below. In several sectors, once-dominant large companies are watching smaller, more agile competitors take meaningful market share. Some were slow to recognise the threat and are slower still to respond with a coherent strategy. This looks structural to me, not a temporary blip.

The growth gap compounds. Quarter after quarter, many midcap and smallcap companies are growing revenues and earnings faster than their larger counterparts. Large caps are growing at perfectly acceptable rates in many cases, but the compounding advantage sits with the smaller end of the market.


The valuation question

The honest counterpoint is that much of this growth is already priced in. Midcap and smallcap valuations are elevated, and that deserves acknowledgment. These segments can also fall sharply and take a long time to recover, as 2008 showed.


But elevated valuations backed by genuine, sustained tailwinds are different from elevated valuations built on speculation alone. The former can grow into their multiples. The latter cannot. Also, remember that at their historical peak, our large caps traded at a PE multiple of over 20, which is higher than what many other global indices command. Why? Because investors expect Indian large caps to grow faster than those in other economies. That doesn’t make the investment case for our large caps bad from a global perspective.


My view, and it is a view, not a guarantee, is that the structural case remains strong enough to justify continued, calibrated exposure to midcaps and smallcaps as part of a well-diversified equity portfolio, if it fits your risk profile and appetite. Given that large caps have been beaten down the most over the past 2 years, they may provide better returns over the short term, giving investors an opportunity for rebalancing. However, the long-term view over the next 4-5 years still supports the midcap and smallcap growth story.


And what about gold? After a strong run, I would not expect the same pace going ahead, and I would not chase it. But the forces behind the rally, such as central bank buying and geopolitical uncertainty, have not disappeared. So I see a case for holding gold as a modest, steady part of a portfolio for diversification, not as a bet on more of the same. As with midcaps, that is a view, not a guarantee.


The real point

Data tells you what happened. Understanding tells you why. Insight tells you what might happen next, and why.


Any tool, app or algorithm can give you the first. Fewer advisors genuinely offer the second. Very few offer the third.


So when you evaluate who is helping you with investment decisions, don’t just ask, “Do they know the historical numbers?” Ask, “Do they have a view on what comes next, and can they explain why?”


That is where the real value of advice lives.





Disclaimer: Nothing in this article is a solicitation, recommendation, endorsement or offer. Past performance of an index, asset class or individual mutual fund scheme is no guarantee of future performance as to returns and risks. We do not take any responsibility for investment decisions based on this article. Please consult your advisor before taking any decisions on your portfolio construction. Registration granted by SEBI, BASL membership, and NISM certification do not guarantee the intermediary’s performance or provide any assurance of returns to investors. Investment in the securities market is subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing.

Comments


Shwealth is the investment advisory arm of Jay Distribution Links. Jay Distribution Links is registered with SEBI as a RIA, registration number
INA000019062. BASL registration number 2153. Shwealth is a separate department of Jay Distribution Links that provide fee only financial advice. 

Please note:
1) Registration granted by SEBI, membership of BASL and certification from NISM in no way guarantee performance of the intermediary or provide any assurance of returns to investors.
2) Investment in securities is subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing.

bottom of page